Ross A. Baker reviewed Thinking in bets by Annie Duke
More a self-help book than a math book
3 stars
The first portion of the book dives into separating luck from skill as she defines what constitutes a good decision. Three recurring examples are:
- Nate Silver's "incorrect" forecast of the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election
- Steve Bartman interfering with the foul ball in the 2003 NLCS
- Pete Carroll's playcall at the end of Super Bowl XLIX
If you still scapegoat any of the three, Duke ably explains why you should reconsider. I'd already exonerated all three, and didn't get much novel out of the setup.
The book transitions more toward psychology and self-help: once we understand that good decisions can have bad outcomes, and vice versa, how do we make better ones. Duke's commentary on escaping our bubble is important, but I had the misfortune of reading it during an election season. The cognitive dissonance between the author imploring me to seek out disagreeable opinions, while the most vile transphobic and …
The first portion of the book dives into separating luck from skill as she defines what constitutes a good decision. Three recurring examples are:
- Nate Silver's "incorrect" forecast of the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election
- Steve Bartman interfering with the foul ball in the 2003 NLCS
- Pete Carroll's playcall at the end of Super Bowl XLIX
If you still scapegoat any of the three, Duke ably explains why you should reconsider. I'd already exonerated all three, and didn't get much novel out of the setup.
The book transitions more toward psychology and self-help: once we understand that good decisions can have bad outcomes, and vice versa, how do we make better ones. Duke's commentary on escaping our bubble is important, but I had the misfortune of reading it during an election season. The cognitive dissonance between the author imploring me to seek out disagreeable opinions, while the most vile transphobic and xenophobic ads played in the background, is not Duke's fault, but also made me want to hurl the book across the room. I need this chapter updated for the toxic environment of October 2024.
The final chapter of the book on balancing short and long term concerns in decision making, presented as "time travel", was the strongest. I could have started here and gotten most of the value.