scienced reviewed Measurement by Paul Lockhart
Review of 'Measurement' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
I first heard of Paul Lockhart when someone mentioned his "Lament" about mathematics teaching and went on to read the "Measurement". This book extends several of the ideas about teaching and reasoning from the "Lament", and makes one re-think what we took for granted about basic theorems and conjectures, mostly in geometry. Many great small problems to entertain oneself while seeing the maths as the creative endeavour that it is.
As a a side note, the negative review with the highest number of 'likes' is completely and utterly out of touch with what the book is about. I'm impressed, however by the eloquence of the review author, and how he attacks first the person, instead of the book or its message:
"...The color green is a significant measure of not just the bananas but my life, at least what remains of it. I don’t know if anyone else uses this …
I first heard of Paul Lockhart when someone mentioned his "Lament" about mathematics teaching and went on to read the "Measurement". This book extends several of the ideas about teaching and reasoning from the "Lament", and makes one re-think what we took for granted about basic theorems and conjectures, mostly in geometry. Many great small problems to entertain oneself while seeing the maths as the creative endeavour that it is.
As a a side note, the negative review with the highest number of 'likes' is completely and utterly out of touch with what the book is about. I'm impressed, however by the eloquence of the review author, and how he attacks first the person, instead of the book or its message:
"...The color green is a significant measure of not just the bananas but my life, at least what remains of it. I don’t know if anyone else uses this measure; it may have only personal appeal. Certainly Lockhart would reject it; he wouldn’t see the point. The title Lockhart has chosen for his book is somewhat misleading. He has nothing to say about the possible significance of green bananas, nor of many other scales of measurement. This is acutely disappointing. It also reflects a fundamental error in what he thinks constitutes measurement. This is acutely dangerous...."