Orlion reviewed Playing to the edge by Michael V. Hayden
Review of 'Playing to the edge' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
This book is a memoir. As such, it is fairly loose in structure and perhaps rambles on a bit. Of course, that's all right with Hayden, he is not writing a study or a textbook. Instead, he intends to humanize the intelligence community.
And boy, does he have a tough task! As director of the NSA and CIA during recent controversial times, he is able to give somewhat of an accounting for publicly maligned acts such as the torture of detainees for information, targeted killings by drones, the collection of meta data of phone calls, and being a Steelers fan.
In the end, I believe he succeeded in this aim. The intelligence community is demonstrated as having its own business culture, humanity, and even massive bureaucracy that prevents it from clandestinely violating human rights as it is often accused of. Add to this some insight into Iran and Pakistan, and …
This book is a memoir. As such, it is fairly loose in structure and perhaps rambles on a bit. Of course, that's all right with Hayden, he is not writing a study or a textbook. Instead, he intends to humanize the intelligence community.
And boy, does he have a tough task! As director of the NSA and CIA during recent controversial times, he is able to give somewhat of an accounting for publicly maligned acts such as the torture of detainees for information, targeted killings by drones, the collection of meta data of phone calls, and being a Steelers fan.
In the end, I believe he succeeded in this aim. The intelligence community is demonstrated as having its own business culture, humanity, and even massive bureaucracy that prevents it from clandestinely violating human rights as it is often accused of. Add to this some insight into Iran and Pakistan, and this is a very informative book.
Those controversial practices will remain controversial, but in the debate of their merits and necessity it helps to have an accurate framework of the circumstances and players. This book helps provide insight into some of the players and gives a better interpretation than "evil secret police" or "Bond-like secret agents."