4thace reviewed Palimpsest by Catherynne M. Valente (duplicate)
Review of 'Palimpsest' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
I used to wonder whether a person could write a novel by writing fabulous scenes full of detail and wonder, and just stringing them together like beads on a string with whatever you would need to make them semi-coherent. Now I think I know.
This is a story which takes place in two worlds, our own and in the dream world of the city-state Palimpsest, and the four main characters who can travel back and forth do so by means of sex with a fellow traveler. It is confusing at first for the listener to know that the character you have just been introduced to in one setting has just gone to a completely different one with different kinds of logic governing how things work and how people think, and more than enough work to try to keep them straight without being burdened with a strong plot driving what is happening. Instead, the yearnings and fears of the characters are the main force behind what happens. There are scenes of what seems like depravity and others straight out of fairy tales frequently alluded to explicitly, and the people who the core four encounter are endowed with their own motivations which you can start to suspect or to trust, and later revise your intuitions about, but it doesn't seem like in the end there is a clear sequence of one thing leading to another and culminating in the outcome we end up with. Fortunately the author is well equipped to provide compelling images draped with sumptuous language to make the whole thing a mostly pleasant experience. I am hazy on what exactly happened, but I have arrived at a state where I don't much care about the facts stated. It's not that kind of book.
The four characters, two male and two female, each have motivations to return to Palimpsest and come to an awareness that they need to do this together if they do it at all. The title is not an accident, because the idea of a scroll which is erased and written over translates into the sexually transmitted tattoos which each traveler accumulates with each linkup, as well as the idea of the reality of the city itself being eradicated and rewritten over all time. Just as a familiar section of a city can fall into ruin, the characters undergo horrific mutilations and sometimes commit them as well. Maybe there are happy well-adjusted people in this world, but I don't remember hearing about any.
So if you are in the mood for a portal fantasy with elements of the weird and macabre, this could be the story for you. I've reviewed some other books with the same level of experimentation going on before and I think this one feel more successful than most from my vantage point, perhaps not from everyone else's. It's put a couple of writing ideas in my mind too, so I wouldn't rule out someday coming up with my own beads on a chain fiction.