I will admit that the writing is pretty good. Every word is chosen wisely and the writing is cohesive. However, a quite interesting story is overshadowed by the most boring plot ever read in a fantasy book. People read fantasy books, because they want smth supernatural, beyond reality and typical human flaws. Here, the character is simple very intelligent. Not the chosen one. Kvothe does not fight any powerful evil character. Also, no action at all. Some harry potter tricks every now and then. This book ends up with a lot of romance and a small piece of fantasy. I am just wondering how it is so overrated. Maybe it is a nice story for teen girls who liked petty, teen magician stories. But surely not an impressive debut, especially in this genre.