maybe 3+: I rated One of Us Is Lying 4 stars. This sequel was still more entertaining than average; but, not as thrilling as the first. Too, there's so much slime. The basic premise is that there's a new round of gossip being dished, by way of a truth or dare game. The original characters still appear (to a lesser degree), with the transition to the new round of main characters being bridged by Bronwyn's little sister, Maeve.