The Seep

mirrorwitch reviewed The Seep by Chana Porter

Review of 'The Seep' on 'Goodreads'

5 stars

Humanity has been finally united, thanks to the psychedelic transcendence brought by our new alien friends, the collective trip-inducing hivemind goop known as The Seep. War is over, poverty is over, capitalism is over, colonialism is over, no one can tolerate exploitation when they're acutely aware of the feelings of everybody else and all the animals and plants and each individual body cell. Art flourishes, new and strange occupations flourish, property is collective and abundant in every regard, endless possibilities open up before ourselves. Guided by the new, hyperempathetic Seep tech, people are modifying their bodies to be furries and cyborgs and anything else they want. Other animals ascend to linguistic sentience and we can talk to them now. Some people opt to live chill lives crafting or Seeping out to cool art shows, others take to exploring the boundaries of identity and personhood itself.

No catch, really. No hidden …

Humanity has been finally united, thanks to the psychedelic transcendence brought by our new alien friends, the collective trip-inducing hivemind goop known as The Seep. War is over, poverty is over, capitalism is over, colonialism is over, no one can tolerate exploitation when they're acutely aware of the feelings of everybody else and all the animals and plants and each individual body cell. Art flourishes, new and strange occupations flourish, property is collective and abundant in every regard, endless possibilities open up before ourselves. Guided by the new, hyperempathetic Seep tech, people are modifying their bodies to be furries and cyborgs and anything else they want. Other animals ascend to linguistic sentience and we can talk to them now. Some people opt to live chill lives crafting or Seeping out to cool art shows, others take to exploring the boundaries of identity and personhood itself.

No catch, really. No hidden dystopia because things are too good. No subtext that wanting things to be better is dangerous. Things are really better. No one in the world disagrees that the Seep made life much better. Well the Seep refusers at the Compound do, but their choice is respected and they're left alone.

Oh and everyone is irrefutably aware of our eternally reborn immortal souls so the weight of mortality, too, is solved forever.

---

"The Seep" by Chana Porter asks the question, what if you're still depressed anyway.

---

What if you know, not through faith but through direct experience, that our immortal souls are immortal, yet you're still grieving. What if you're still grieving after years and you blocked away everyone and you're living in paradise but your living room is a rotting mess and you can't be bothered to even try. What if you can't enjoy any of this shiny new world because your lesbian girlfriend enjoyed it in a way that took her beyond your reach and the saccharine voice of The Seep only adds to the wound. What if everyone is happy and you want to shoot something. someone? yourself? you found a gun...

---

Short, focused novel in the style currently trending. Takes directions I wouldn't expect. Main character is trans and in the world portrayed that almost doesn't matter, except it then does. I like this one quite a bit.

enne📚 reviewed The Seep by Chana Porter

4 stars

Content warning minor spoilers

This short novel is about "the softest invasion" of earth, by an alien lifeform called The Seep that infiltrates the drinking water and causes humans to hear each other's thoughts, feel joy and peace, gain immortality, and also be able to magically transform themselves and the world around them. The Seep loves humans (like an overprotective parent) and wants to help humans create a perfect world (whatever that means).

But, if anything, this soft-but-creepy invasion by the Seep is more of a backdrop to the narrator Trina's own grief, and her anger about changes in the world. The arc of the book is mostly a very personal one focused inwardly on the narrator; the climax of the book, even as it is very explicitly a confrontation with The Seep itself is ultimately an internal and emotional one.

The Seep is a neat alien overall and was a lot of fun to read, especially as most of what we see of it is not some on page monster but instead is only visible through the changed interactions of other humans. And, I like a book complaining about capitalism as much as the next person, but it was also refreshing to have this book magically wave past such problems into some further future with its own issues.

The fact that humans are able to suddenly understand each other's feelings and suffering via the Seep turns the world into a (terrifying?) neverending therapy processing session. Some of this reminds me of the vibes of Lois McMaster Bujold's Shards of Honor, where Cordelia goes back to Beta Colony and is constantly harassed about therapy until she escapes. I think The Seep's patience and implacability also remind me some of the Oankali in Lilith's Brood, where they hold all the cards and think they know best for humans.

The main character is a butch trans woman who laments the wild clothing and appearance changes that the rest of the world goes through, feeling lost about how to be butch and what feels comfortable for her in these new spaces. And maybe this is spot on for Trina herself, who is mostly just angry about change as a character trait, but at one point there's a line: "She’d fought and kicked and clawed to have her insides match her outsides, and now people changed their faces as easily as getting a haircut." Mostly this was jarring to me because universally most trans folks I know would be overjoyed for others to more easily be able to change their bodies.

Overall, this had some really neat ideas, wrapped up with a good emotional arc, and I enjoyed it quite a bit.

I read this because it's on the Otherwise Award's 2020 Honor List: otherwiseaward.org/award/2020-otherwise-award/2020-honor-list

Goblin reviewed The Seep by Chana Porter

The Seep

4 stars

The Seep is a story about grief, more than anything else. The description of how Trina deals with her grief is well written. But I give the book only 3 stars because it feels shallow. How do we have multiple characters who turn out to be so important to Trina and her journey, without us learning much about them? I finished the book in an evening, and felt that perhaps something important had gone over my head because the story just seemed to be missing something. Trina is native, and Jewish, and trans. Does any of her identity and cultural background influence how she deals with the world created by the arrival of the Seep? It feels like it should be relevant, and I can speculate, but if there were hints from the author I missed them.

Despite the shallowness, the parts that are there are very good. Porter creates …

The Seep is a story about grief, more than anything else. The description of how Trina deals with her grief is well written. But I give the book only 3 stars because it feels shallow. How do we have multiple characters who turn out to be so important to Trina and her journey, without us learning much about them? I finished the book in an evening, and felt that perhaps something important had gone over my head because the story just seemed to be missing something. Trina is native, and Jewish, and trans. Does any of her identity and cultural background influence how she deals with the world created by the arrival of the Seep? It feels like it should be relevant, and I can speculate, but if there were hints from the author I missed them.

Despite the shallowness, the parts that are there are very good. Porter creates a really interesting world, a utopia where our material needs are met and the horrors of capitalism are in the past. Utopias seem like they should be dull to write about but Porter proves this wrong.

After finishing the book, I learned that a friend has a different edition that also includes a short story that goes into more detail about the boy and Horizon. Perhaps that edition would have felt more complete to me.

Remy Rose

rated it

Jun 11