User Profile

I have a few more minor rambling thoughts about Litany for a Broken World too, which I'll separate out into this comment.

This is my own fault for coming into a book with expectations, but the blurb I read focuses on three strangers. I was thus a bit surprised that all nine major characters in the book (including the dog!) get their own point of view chapters, and this jumping around didn't quite work for me as a reader. It felt a bit unfocused to me, but maybe it worked well for some other reader. Additionally, Harnett getting his own chapter also removed some of the ambiguity around Jace and Corinne's conflict. It would have been more effective for me to have him be a bit of an enigma (and fill in his backstory later, if needed).

Jace and Corinne's conflict was really intriguing to me, but I feel like the resolution fizzled. There's betrayal, mistrust, and ambiguity about the nature of the Network, RDD, and Harnett. But then there's a moment during the climax, where Harnett repeats the facts that Corinne believes (as far as I could tell), and Corinne suddenly wonders "is this actually true?" without much reason at all. It didn't feel like a believable moment of doubt to me.

Finally, I do love a multiverse story, but I wish a little that there had been more explanation or differentiation in the other worlds. I don't know that they quite felt that different or unique. Is the handwave at "you can't travel to any world that's too close" the way that you don't meet your own self in another world? Mostly I have just seen a number of stories doing this sort of thing, and so I'm intrigued about the mechanics of this universe. This book just doesn't really get into any of them.

There's a lot of neat things going on in this book, but there's also a number of things that didn't quite land for me. I'm struggling to have a solid opinion, so here's a mishmash of drive-by thoughts.

I do love this book's thematic mantra of fixing broken things. It's clear that many characters in this book are broken (emotionally), and it's clear that the Boston timeline is broken (structurally, via capitalism largely), but it's less clear to me what sort of fixing is truly going on, especially in a multiverse sense.

Obviously Martin, Stirling, and Melissa are putting in work for their community, but the rest of it just seems like talk (or something a future book in the series will get to). I wish there was more clarity about how Jace had broken his oath to repair the broken parts of the universe, and what that oath actually means to Jace and Corinne. (Has Harnett sworn this same oath? Also, what is this oath as compared to the Network's "greatest good" motto??)

I think the pacing of the end of the book is also a little harmed by this being part of a series. There's clearly a climactic confrontation, but it largely feels unresolved, leaving lots of pieces for the future.

This sounds like a lot of complaints, but I enjoyed my read here. I do love a telepathic dog. I love the idea of talking to a therapist about portals to other worlds. I love Jace and Corinne working together for a shared goal while also being so misaligned. I love Martin still working to care for Reina even when Reina is not his sister. Overall, my favorite part of this book was all of the characters.

(This was the #SFFBookClub book for March 2026.)

Does anyone want a “cozy” story about the grief of disappointing your friends, and the agony of saying “no”?

Maybe it's my age, but I think I can always deeply appreciate a story centered on the idea of a change in life direction--there's a job that's consumed you to the point of you making it your identity and suddenly it's taken away from you (see: Bujold's Memory), or where a fulfilling job that your family and friends all expect you to do that has lost its luster, or when you've been doing the same job for hundreds of years and who would you even be if you weren't doing that. I am just a sucker for stories about new directions.

It's not that Viv wasn't changing her life in Legends & Lattes, but she wasn't really struggling against herself: she knew she wanted to hang up her sword and open a fantasy coffee shop. It doesn't quite resonate the same way as Fern's struggle does in this book, and it makes this book much stronger. Honestly, I most appreciate that this Travis Baldree book has an answer to the "how do I change my life when it's not working" question that doesn't end directly in fantasy small business. I also appreciate that Astryx and Fern are both thematically struggling with their own relationships with their own work, and have different answers to that question.

This is still a fluffy story (and if L&L wasn't your thing, I don't know that I'd recommend this one to you), but this is absolutely the strongest book in the trilogy for me.

Additional minor rambling:

Because Zyll is an uncontainable goblin menace and Astryx is on a hopeless quest to contain her while somehow bringing her to justice, it creates a nice plot dynamic. Astryx doesn't have to be the terrible mercenary out to get a bounty on a loveable side character--it can be comic relief where Zyll escapes her bonds but then comes along anyway. It removes some seriousness, and makes it more about the relationships between the characters. And, Zyll at least gets some explanation in the end for her behavior, so it's not entirely fluff either.

(I think also you might want to have read Goblins & Greatcoats to get an introduction to Zyll and the titular breadknife. It's not that important, but it also makes that appearance of the titular breadknife even more random without that morsel of backstory.)

If I had any negatives, it's that I still squint so hard at the economics of this world. The threat in this story is that friends will be disappointed in you. There is very little worry around the fact that you (and your friends) have invested huge amounts of money in opening a bookstore business in a new town. In some ways, I feel like the small business capitalism aspect of these books undermines the cozy flavor that it's going for. I think there's just a dissonance to me where concerns about money are brushed under the rug and there's an assumption that everybody and everything will be fine without any worldbuilding or explanation for why that is.

Fun, short, quotable.

The first book in this series was a riff on the Fall of the House of Usher (that we read for #SFFBookClub), and the second book intersected quite well with Easton's war trauma. This third book reads like a monster of the week but without much else going on in terms of themes or character development. A good snack of a romp, but not very filling.

(Also, shaking my head that there's no Eugenia Potter in this one either. It does at least have Gallacian rock pronouns going for it though.)

The biggest feeling I come away from James Islington's Hierarchy series is that it seems like it should appeal to fans of Brandon Sanderson. If the first book was an introduction to the world and young protagonist, this second book is much happier to dish out worldbuilding details about what's going on in the larger world(s). It's a grippy action book, and the way the worldbuilding is slowly revealed is my favorite part of this book. The second book also manages to pull out its own big ending surprises to drive who knows what will happen in the next one.

My biggest complaint is that this is primarily a plot-driven book and the protagonist is a bit too special. If there is a competition or challenge of any sort, Vis is going to overcome it every single time, no matter the odds, and no matter if he's never fought in magic armor or snuck into a pyramid or driven in a magic chariot race or trained to be a dancer or whatever. The book doesn't leave that much room for characterization, and secondary characters are pretty heavy-handed about their one-note thematic opinions.

Overall, I just wish the characters were a bit less flat. I feel like this is the kind of book I would have devoured when I was younger, but cool worldbuilding isn't quite enough sustenance these days.

The situation was terrifying, but the project itself was awesome.

A bunch of my friends were rereading this book before the movie came out, so I thought I'd join along. Project Hail Mary is another space engineering procedural with Andy Weir protagonist voice. The characters are pretty thin, but I think you're reading this for the science problem solving. I always appreciate interspersed flashbacks (especially here where there's a bit of a reason why Grace continues to remember more over time).

I also personally don't know that this book makes for especially great movie material, but what do I know. (On this reread, there was also some airquotes jokes that really didn't land for me along the lines of "wow it'd be bad if I were fatphobic/racist/a pedophile" and I'm throwing a few side eyes.)

joke tagline: a secret former prince struggles to move up the ladder at magic school for future senators in post-apocalyptic fantasy Rome

It's grippy. It's bloody and violent at times. The fantasy worldbuilding was fun. I wouldn't quite say it's YA, but it is also a young protagonist in a school setting where some moments resonate with the Hunger Games. It was enjoyable in a childhood need for fantasy book with a young protagonist in a capitalist-metaphor magic dystopia sort of way.

What this book does especially well for me is how many different directions it pulls the main character in. He's keeping his past a secret and trying to follow his own goals while simultaneously investigating a mystery, being suborned by rebels, and trying to succeed at school. There's a lot of lying and sneaking that's delicious. Being overconstrained by external forces helps balance out the plot elements of Vis being too capable across multiple disciplines.

It's also got some excellent plot twists (more like twist of the knife for Vis) as well as some wild worldbuilding at the end setting up for who knows what book two (or three or four) will look like.

@Tak@reading.taks.garden I wish bookwyrm had better fields for editor / illustrator so that it didn't make it look like Litany for a Broken World was written by Karen Conlin

I guess I could re-add them all in a different order??