Remy Rose reviewed Who Goes There? by William F. Nolan
Review of 'Who Goes There?' on 'Storygraph'
5 stars
Loved it. This is my first Campbell story, and I hope the rest are as good. I'm not sure whether it's a fair comparison, but I would say this out-Lovecrafts Lovecraft, whose collected works I'm about 3 quarters into. The Thing is undoubtedly quite unnameable, nearly indescribable, incomprehensible to our human minds; yet unlike Lovecraft, Campbell manages to describe The Thing with words other than just unnameable, indescribable, or incomprehensible. He's willing to let his characters at least conjecture a bit about this Thing's nature. Although perhaps pondering about the imponderable is ultimately futile, it does make for some much needed philosophical brain fuel. I'll leave this review shorter than the story deserves, in light of the many, significantly better, reviews it already has.
Loved it. This is my first Campbell story, and I hope the rest are as good. I'm not sure whether it's a fair comparison, but I would say this out-Lovecrafts Lovecraft, whose collected works I'm about 3 quarters into. The Thing is undoubtedly quite unnameable, nearly indescribable, incomprehensible to our human minds; yet unlike Lovecraft, Campbell manages to describe The Thing with words other than just unnameable, indescribable, or incomprehensible. He's willing to let his characters at least conjecture a bit about this Thing's nature. Although perhaps pondering about the imponderable is ultimately futile, it does make for some much needed philosophical brain fuel. I'll leave this review shorter than the story deserves, in light of the many, significantly better, reviews it already has.