Reviews and Comments

Alex Cabe

CitizenCabe@books.theunseen.city

Joined 3 years ago

It's not like I'm a preachy crybaby who can't resist giving overemotional speeches about hope all the time.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Rudyard Kipling: Barrack-room ballads (2003, Signet Classic) No rating

Continuing my practice of reading a poem every day. Picked this because I like "Danny Deever" from Starship Troopers and "Boots", which I first saw in the 28 Years Later trailer.

Going to be an exercise is separating the art from the political context.

Jason Reynolds: Long Way Down (Hardcover, 2017, Atheneum)

Verse may work better on the page.

This was a very cool premise and Will had a relentlessly tragic life. I would have like the ghost characters to be sketched out a little more fully.

I appreciated the choice not to have a firm conclusion.

I wish I had read this on the page instead so I could appreciate the verse better, but I did enjoy having it read by the author.

Marina Diamandis: Eat the World (2024, Penguin Books, Limited)

For the first time, platinum-certified singer-songwriter Marina shares her singular observations of the human heart …

Satisfying Arc

A lot of these aren't great in isolation, but taken as a whole they give a great glimpse of Marina's mind and have a complete, satisfying arc.

Individual favorites are:

Starlight Water Space Fresh Air Fizz Four Seasons Tiny Leopards

David Ly, Daniel Zomparelli: Queer Little Nightmares (2022, Arsenal Pulp Press)

Stories were stronger than the poems.

I found these generally took more effort that reading a regular novel because each time you have to adjust to the world of the story, you can't just dip in and out.

The stories I liked the most were the "Black Mirror" style ones where there was a strange technology or a twist. The "queer person turns into a monster" stories kind of ran together for me.

I also liked the stories for non-Western cultures that explored their own monsters.

Of the poems, Floral Arrangement I was the one I liked the best.

Malka Older: The Mimicking of Known Successes (Hardcover, 2023, Tordotcom)

The Mimicking of Known Successes presents a cozy Holmesian murder mystery and sapphic romance, set …

A promising setting, a little light on mystery

The world building here doesn't fundamentally make sense, there's no universe in which building 200,000 mile rails to colonize Jupiter is more feasible in terms of knowhow or resources that fixing Earth or even colonizing the Moon or Mars. However, you owe it to the author to suspend disbelief on the central premise and go for the ride. The worldbuilding about all the heat and light coming from gas flames was so good it felt like it was the initial idea that the setting formed around.

The strengths were the worldbuilding and the formal language that made everything feel retro-futuristic.

The primary weakness, in my view, was that a good mystery often involves a unique or creative "perfect crime". In order to write a perfect crime, you have to work within the rules of the real world. If your perfect crime involves a creative interpretation of a fictional …

Jessica Townsend (duplicate): Nevermoor: Nevermoor: The Trials of Morrigan Crow Book 1 (2017, Little, Brown and Company)

A cursed girl escapes death and finds herself in a magical world-but is then tested …

At Midnight, Jupiter North will Kill Dumbledore with an E-tool

This is prime.

Nevermoor was a great series starter with a fun, imaginative world and a cast of funny, relatable characters. Morrigan and Jupiter were fun in different ways, the story was propulsive, and the worldbuilding was Dahl-esque, with confidence and verve.

The Christmas Eve chapter was wonderful and heartwarming, I want to read it every Christmas.

Casey McQuiston: The Pairing (Paperback, 2024, St. Martin's Griffin)

The wildly anticipated new novel from the author of the bestselling phenomenon Red, White and …

Middle of the Road Romance

Theo was a worse person than Kit but a better narrator and Theo's section were more fun to read. Kit's sections were more of a chore and I didn't much like how he described things.

Theo was a good example of a nonbinary character and someone who was emotionally closed off.

The characters could be frustrating when they made up reasons not to be together. I get that that's kind of the point, but it rankled over the course of the whole book.

Wish fulfillment book that was honest about what it was. Author was clearly putting themselves in the role of Theo.

I'm not a foodie so the food descriptions didn't do it for me. Not the author's fault, but I sometimes felt like I was missing out.

Martin Summers: Madness in the City of Magnificent Intentions

More research than writing focused.

This was very deeply researched and very academic. Summers did a deep dive into decades and decades of archives. I especially appreciated when individual case studies were used to illustrate a point in the hospital's history.

The book didn't really feel like it put parts together. This had much more value as a presentation of research than a piece of writing. I had trouble latching onto a coherent thesis or throughline.

Anna-Marie McLemore: Lakelore (Hardcover, 2022, Feiwel & Friends)

In this young adult novel by award-winning author Anna-Marie McLemore, two non-binary teens are pulled …

Tight focus on the characters' inner lives

This sort of reminded me of the Netflix series Adolescence in that I found it more interesting as conceptual exercise than a story.

The book is in (usually) very short chapters and jumps back and forth between the viewpoint characters. In that way it's kind of an ADHD simulator. Early in the book I found it hard to tell Bastian and Lore apart from each other. That's sort of a commentary on how we tend to classify and box people in by ethnicity and gender expression, but it also forced me to take notes to remember which character was which. Later in the book we learned how Lore had to keep notes for everything, so the book succeeded at putting me into the shoes of the character.

This was a small story that focused on the inner lives of the two viewpoint characters and everyone else was pretty …