Reviews and Comments

Catship

catship@books.theunseen.city

Joined 3 years, 10 months ago

We're a plural system who loves queer & anarchist scifi.

But recently we just read a few randomly picked up mystery books in a row, in German, and we tend to review books in the language we read them in. That or similar may happen again, be warned.

No reading goals, just feelings.

This link opens in a pop-up window

finished reading The Extraordinaries by TJ Klune (The Extraordinaries, #1)

TJ Klune: The Extraordinaries (2020, Tor Teen) No rating

Some people are extraordinary. Some are just extra. New York Times bestselling author TJ Klune's …

I made it through, so clearly i found some things good about this book, but ooof i was annoyed a lot of the time. Mainly by it being extremely slow-paced. I think the story would have worked out better for me if it was about a third or maybe half of its lenght. A bit like the kind of fanfic that Nick writes, actually. But also, while I was hopeful in the beginning that it would be at least a tiny bit critical towards that profession, it turned more and more into an ode to cops towards the end. And the reporter who is described by Nick in terms of misogynist tropes and then actually turns out to be as horrible as he says was an annoying move too. I might still read book 2 🙄

K. A. Linde: The Robin on the Oak Throne (2025, Pan Macmillan) No rating

This series.... idk. It took me a few tries to get through this book. Just like the first, it's about a young woman who lives and works with sexy asshole monster dudes, which is all a bit threatening, but her world has always been that, and now her friends are also part of the monster powerplay bullshit world. There's always some bi flirting, which I appreciate. There's too much details of penetrative sex for my taste. But in this book.... there's a horrible therapy session, a real bad example, that somehow still feels like "look, even this tough person tries therapy". And some other things that felt like real life references that didn't really work out.

reviewed Le Sorcier de la Montagne de Feu by Ian Livingstone (Un Livre dont vous êtes le Héros: Défis Fantastiques)

Ian Livingstone, Steve Jackson, Camille Fabien: Le Sorcier de la Montagne de Feu (Paperback, French language, Gallimard Jeunesse) No rating

it's working

No rating

Ok so the first time i quite literally got struck by lightning when i was almost through. I'm going in for a second time, so my plan to learn some french by reading trashy fantasy choose your own adventure things that are fun enough to keep me going without understanding everything is working. It is pretty trashy too, it's basically just fighting random creatures and getting lost in the mountain.

Heather Fawcett: Emily Wilde's Compendium of Lost Tales (EBook, 2025, Del Rey) No rating

Emily Wilde has spent her life studying faeries. A renowned dryadologist, she has documented hundreds …

Finally, Emily has a cozy little family to keep her company while she's, uuh, being the queen of a drama heavy fairy kingdom.

I finished this a few days ago. It's a lot of fun, basically Emily is going on an expedition with a larger and more neurodiverse group than she's really comfortable with, and a lot of entertaining-from-the-outside/horrifying stuff happens, for variously good reasons. Waiting for that third book in the library app!

Charlotte McConaghy: Once There Were Wolves (Hardcover, 2021, Flatiron Books)

Inti Flynn arrives in Scotland with her twin sister, Aggie, to lead a team of …

It's very similar to Migrations in some ways: the way the personal, societal and ecological blend and make the story really hard to summarise, for example. It's about things like wolves and violent men and trauma and knowing what is dangerous and what it is even happening. The world feels more real and the storytelling more polished, which leads to an even more perfectly frustrating reading experience. I kept begging the book not to go certain ways, and it mostly obeyed, luckily.

Jonathan Stroud: Legendary Scarlett and Browne (2025, Random House Children's Books) No rating

It took me a while to get back into the story. It's certainly a fun story with tons of absurd escapes, but not very fluffy, as everything is pretty horrible, the world and the situations, and all the relationship stuff can only do so much.

Heather Fawcett: Emily Wilde's Encyclopaedia of Faeries (2023, Random House Worlds)

A curmudgeonly professor journeys to a small town in the far north to study faerie …

I liked it. The plot is basically that an autistic-coded scholar goes to a remote village to research fairies, and learns a ton about them through a few medium-sized desasters while also getting unexpectedly comfy with the human locals. I liked how some of the locals learn to suggest ways of hanging out that work better for Emily than the tavern. There were some things though that made me really nervous because they reminded me of things I dislike about myself.

T. Kingfisher: Hemlock and Silver (2025, Pan Macmillan)

"From New York Times bestselling and Hugo Award-winning author T. Kingfisher comes Hemlock & Silver, …

Liked it :) not as much as T. Kingfisher's other fairy tale stories that I've read so far, but there's sweet characters and the plot is fun. I especially enjoyed how all the disclaimers around Anja's healer title are handled.

Fiona Sironic: Am Samstag gehen die Mädchen in den Wald und jagen Sachen in die Luft (Hardcover, HarperCollins, Ecco Verlag)

Eine erste Liebe zwischen Festhalten und Vernichten, Aussterben und Weiterleben

Es brennt. In den …

Also ich hab es vor allem wegen dem Titel lesen wollen. Es war dann aber schon ein bisschen überraschend. Es ist eine queere Klimakrisen-Story über das Internet, unter anderem. Eras Tante muss ungefähr so alt sein wie ich, sie kennt Foren und frische Zwiebeln und die Bananen, die es aktuell gibt, aber keine Modem-Töne. Zwischen Wetter-Extremen und Kapitalismus bleibt ein Wohnprojekt als Zuhause, das vor allem ein Gartenprojekt ist, und der Luxus essbarer frischer Pflanzen ist für Era und ihre Mutter aber durch die vielen, vielen Mitbewohnis und offenen Türen getrübt. Und dann ist die Geschichte nach ausgestorbenen Vögeln strukturiert, was mich an "Migrations" von Charlotte McConaghy erinntert hat, aber doch sehr anders ist. Insgesamt.... bisschen sperrig, bisschen langsam, bisschen das awkwarde Gefühl, mit der Autorin unbekannter Weise vor 15 Jahren in angrenzenden Twitter-Bubbles gewesen zu sein. Ich mag es.

Merlin Sheldrake: Entangled Life (Paperback, 2021, Vintage)

The more we learn about fungi, the less makes sense without them. They can change …

I listened to this while dozing so i missed most of the cool science. Still, i picked up a lot of fun facts, and the book was the opposite of dry... it was a bit squelchy, like something decomposing. Would definitely recommend.

Samin Nosrat: Good Things (Hardcover) No rating

I love Samin Nosrat's other book, and the show, and the Home Cooking podcast, so I expected to love this too. I didn't. I think part of it was that it didn't work well for me as an audio book, at least not one to listen to while doing counting-heavy crochet. It would have needed more attention to get all the the cooking advice. But also.... I think the message of the book was supposed to be that food is an everyday thing and it's important to make food that works and is enjoyable for you. Instead, i kept wishing i was someone else. Someone who likes cilantro, for example, because Samin Nosrat likes cilantro and i want to share that joy! Oof. Maybe it wasn't the right moment for this book.