kydnmthws reviewed 9-11 by Noam Chomsky
None
4 stars
Brilliant writing, deeply ideologically confused. Are you racist? Are you not racist? Are you just anti-imperialist with a luddite-esque attitude toward conquerors?
This link opens in a pop-up window
Brilliant writing, deeply ideologically confused. Are you racist? Are you not racist? Are you just anti-imperialist with a luddite-esque attitude toward conquerors?
May 2025 - Very different than the series in form; the lack of visual makes the narrator feel much less 'actual', closer to Esther Greenwood. They are very different things, and I think the main measure of that is that the novel is so hopeless. 3.75/5
November 2025 - Offred c'est moi 5/5
May 2025 - Very different than the series in form; the lack of visual makes the narrator feel much less 'actual', closer to Esther Greenwood. They are very different things, and I think the main measure of that is that the novel is so hopeless. 3.75/5
November 2025 - Offred c'est moi 5/5
Lost momentum halfway through. The existential gloom of growing up is saturating, like a bad spill. But I can't really feel sorry for either of them
Ambitious in conception, but none of the writing was that ambitious at all. Mary Shelley wrote Frankenstein in the first industrial revolution with so much more. Brave New World is conceptually brilliant, but it lacks the proper organisation to make it actualise that brilliance.