Miriam Robern rated Witch King: 3 stars

Witch King by Martha Wells (The Rising World, Book 1)
Kai-Enna is the Witch King, though he hasn’t always been, and he hasn’t even always been Kai-Enna!
After being …
Housewife who reads and writes on the side.
In another life I got a BA in English Literature, which means I've read all the white men authors. I'm now making up for lost time by reading all the women authors and queer authors and authors of colour.
This link opens in a pop-up window

Kai-Enna is the Witch King, though he hasn’t always been, and he hasn’t even always been Kai-Enna!
After being …
Very strong first and second act, with well-developed characters and an intriguing view of transgender life in Regency England. Sadly the third act does not live up to the promise of the first two and gets a little muddled.
Very strong first and second act, with well-developed characters and an intriguing view of transgender life in Regency England. Sadly the third act does not live up to the promise of the first two and gets a little muddled.
Really enjoyed this fun, sapphic romp through Victorian England. Characters are engaging, plot is pleasantly twisty, historical call-outs are satisfying.
Really enjoyed this fun, sapphic romp through Victorian England. Characters are engaging, plot is pleasantly twisty, historical call-outs are satisfying.

John and Emily are a perfectly normal couple living in near-future suburban America, with plans to attend a perfectly normal …
Olivia Waite is one of my favourite authors, but this novella is like a reduced sauce that delivers exactly what I love about Waite in a delightfully small package. The characters are well-drawn, the setting is quaintly realized, the conflicts aren't superficial, and the affection, both between the characters and between me and the characters, is incredible.
My only complaint is that it's so short! :)
Olivia Waite is one of my favourite authors, but this novella is like a reduced sauce that delivers exactly what I love about Waite in a delightfully small package. The characters are well-drawn, the setting is quaintly realized, the conflicts aren't superficial, and the affection, both between the characters and between me and the characters, is incredible.
My only complaint is that it's so short! :)
A solid blossoming of the world and characters set down in Dreadnought. Danny develops into a more fully realized character in relatively simple and straightforward ways, but the secondary cast absolutely blooms into detail and colour. The worldbuilding deepens appreciably: the Marvel and DC homages are still there, but significantly muted in favour of this world's particularities.
SPOILERS: I do feel like the book could have used a content warning regarding its forced detransition plotline—I was surprised by it and a little shaken for the rest of the day—but these things are difficult to accomplish in print media.
A solid blossoming of the world and characters set down in Dreadnought. Danny develops into a more fully realized character in relatively simple and straightforward ways, but the secondary cast absolutely blooms into detail and colour. The worldbuilding deepens appreciably: the Marvel and DC homages are still there, but significantly muted in favour of this world's particularities.
SPOILERS: I do feel like the book could have used a content warning regarding its forced detransition plotline—I was surprised by it and a little shaken for the rest of the day—but these things are difficult to accomplish in print media.
Superheroes aren't even my thing but I really enjoyed Dreadnought. It's got some solid worldbuilding, itself undergirded by a sophisticated but still compassionate worldview. Characters are well drawn and even if they are derived from tropes, their development delves underneath those tropes to reveal complexities underneath.
Superheroes aren't even my thing but I really enjoyed Dreadnought. It's got some solid worldbuilding, itself undergirded by a sophisticated but still compassionate worldview. Characters are well drawn and even if they are derived from tropes, their development delves underneath those tropes to reveal complexities underneath.
Deftly told story of a new kid who comes to school, disappointed that there's no gymnastics team, and is convinced to join cheer, instead. Oh, and discovers she's trans along the way.
Super cute teen romance, solid foundation of 90s pop culture and reference landmarks, evocative perspectives from the two POV characters. Heartfelt struggles and satisfying wins.
Looking forward to Book Two!
Deftly told story of a new kid who comes to school, disappointed that there's no gymnastics team, and is convinced to join cheer, instead. Oh, and discovers she's trans along the way.
Super cute teen romance, solid foundation of 90s pop culture and reference landmarks, evocative perspectives from the two POV characters. Heartfelt struggles and satisfying wins.
Looking forward to Book Two!
Content warning Spoileriffic!
Look, I know. I understand. I am an English major. I get the historical background and the publishing realities and blah de blah de blah-blah. I understand why the story ends the way it does. That doesn't make it a good ending or even the right ending.
I loved this book from the start right up to the penultimate chapter. The titular awakening is complex, grounded, and masterfully articulated. Edna becomes a real person! It's amazing! And then she throws it all away in what can only be described as a fit of pique. The last chapter blows.
This book should be taught, and it should be taught as a tragedy. Not that the story itself is a tragedy, but the story's conception, context, and publication as a tragedy. We all deserve better than Chopin and The Awakening got, and this novel can serve as a very depressing signpost along the way to getting to that better world.
Sleek and streamlined, this is a story optimized for speed. It's a quick read, but not a vapid one. The characters are deftly rendered in minimalist strokes and the plot moves forward quickly and inexorably, like an endurance run. Crossing the finish line is well worth it.
Sleek and streamlined, this is a story optimized for speed. It's a quick read, but not a vapid one. The characters are deftly rendered in minimalist strokes and the plot moves forward quickly and inexorably, like an endurance run. Crossing the finish line is well worth it.
Zoe Storm writes a great transition-romance story today, and this is one of her earliest forays. Which is to say: it's simple, straightforward, and well-executed. It's light on the startling insights into the human condition but the characters are well drawn, the conflicts paced nicely, and the plot pays off in a wholly satisfying way. It's an early work, but it's still a solid creative effort.
Zoe Storm writes a great transition-romance story today, and this is one of her earliest forays. Which is to say: it's simple, straightforward, and well-executed. It's light on the startling insights into the human condition but the characters are well drawn, the conflicts paced nicely, and the plot pays off in a wholly satisfying way. It's an early work, but it's still a solid creative effort.
Villaneuve draws some deft characters with maddening hangups crashing into each other's lives, wanting to connect while not wanting to want to connect because they have so many other bigger priorities. It's profoundly satisfying to see them get over themselves.
(Also there are girls kissing which is my only barometer of quality any more.)
Villaneuve draws some deft characters with maddening hangups crashing into each other's lives, wanting to connect while not wanting to want to connect because they have so many other bigger priorities. It's profoundly satisfying to see them get over themselves.
(Also there are girls kissing which is my only barometer of quality any more.)
This book series started as a jokey premise but it grew into something much more and in its third installment it is blossoming into incredible colour, incisive commentary, and challenging themes. Greaves continues to deliver powerful plotting, charming prose, and fascinating character portraits.
I'd say I cannot wait to see where this goes but I'm going to have to wait regardless.
This book series started as a jokey premise but it grew into something much more and in its third installment it is blossoming into incredible colour, incisive commentary, and challenging themes. Greaves continues to deliver powerful plotting, charming prose, and fascinating character portraits.
I'd say I cannot wait to see where this goes but I'm going to have to wait regardless.