Reviews and Comments

Optional Locked account

optional@books.theunseen.city

Joined 1 year, 2 months ago

Queer girl reading

Full book reviews: blog.optional.page/optionalbooks

Pronouns: she/they Mastodon: @Optional@dice.camp Home: my.optional.page

This link opens in a pop-up window

Extremely Online (Hardcover, 2023, Simon & Schuster) 1 star

Acclaimed Washington Post reporter Taylor Lorenz presents a groundbreaking social history of the internet—revealing how …

Extremely Boring

1 star

Written very much as a factual account of the platforms that saw some popularity in the US, and a selection of people that were most popular on these platforms this book provides next to nothing in the way of commentary or analysis. Full review here

commented on Extremely Online by Taylor Lorenz

Extremely Online (Hardcover, 2023, Simon & Schuster) 1 star

Acclaimed Washington Post reporter Taylor Lorenz presents a groundbreaking social history of the internet—revealing how …

I'm about 50 pages in and this is really bad. The author is a WaPo reporter and it completely shines through. Every section ends with a cliffhanger ("But MySpace wouldn't stay on top for long" or "But nobody believed blogging could turn a profit"). And the author does no commentary in her own voice. She lays out the history of some platform or fad using a couple of people as examples and then quotes journalists and celebrities commenting on that. It promises a "social history of social media" which I took to mean an exploration of society and culture either online or shaped through the online. Instead, it's individuals standing in as examples for eras of online life. Also, the view is extremely US centric, but that could just be because social media has its roots there.

It's very quick to read though, so I'll probably still finish it.

finished reading The Listening Society by Hanzi Freinacht

The Listening Society (Paperback, 2017, Metamoderna ApS) 5 stars

Whew that took me 3 months. The ideas presented seem to have great merit, and the book as a whole has "major implications" (as it states itself). The last quarter wasn't as dense as the beginning, but everything got tied into a coherent whole at the end. The writing style probably isn't everyone's cup of tea, but I mostly enjoyed it. Full review will follow, but I can already say that this is a must read for anyone who wants to understand >>>society<<<.