Reviews and Comments

Guy Montag

Montag@books.theunseen.city

Joined 2 years, 5 months ago

Simply put, I love to read. My first job was at a library. Even when I was a full-time grad student in addition to working 40-60 hours per week, I still managed to finish about a book per week for pleasure.

Firmly in camp Dewey Decimal.

Some of my favorite genres: - Beer brewing - Computers - Cyberpunk - Dogs - Environmentalism - Finance - History - Novels about the British upper class (though I have no interest in the Royal Family) - Outdoors - Poetry - Running - Spies - Travel

This link opens in a pop-up window

started reading Picks and Shovels by Cory Doctorow (The Martin Hench Novels, #3)

Cory Doctorow: Picks and Shovels (EBook, 2025, Bloomsbury Publishing Plc., Tor Books) No rating

New York Times bestselling author Cory Doctorow returns to the world of Red Team Blues …

I'm about halfway through the book so far but I'm struggling. I like Cory Doctorow's books and articles, and I enjoyed the first two Martin Hench books.

My problem in Picks and Shovels is the Rivka character. Doctorow constantly reminds us that she's a Charedi Jew, but she doesn't act like one at all. She has Shabbat dinner on Saturday night, eats non-kosher food, attends interfaith prayers and has no problem being alone in a room with a man. The part about her parents trying to set her up with a boy feels more like the Sicily scenes in The Godfather than how actual Charedi Jews meet their spouses. That doesn't get into the complicated relationship between Charedim and computers which is not even mentioned.

I believe Doctorow is Jewish, but I still expected more from him. This is worse than lazy stereotyping - it's lazy wrong stereotyping.

Carr, Jack (Joint pseudonym): The terminal list (2018) 4 stars

"A Navy SEAL has nothing left to live for and everything to kill for after …

Macho revenge and conspiracy porn

3 stars

Let's start with the obvious: this is not a good book. The good characters are all perfect Mary Sues and the bad characters have no redeeeming characteristics. The main character can magically find whoever he needs within a day, no matter where they are. The bad guys, on the other hand, can almost never find the hero, even when they have the full power of the US government and military. Whenever they come close to catching him, they always allow an easy escape route.

That said, there's a reason people like porn. The Terminal List is an easy read that provides action without spending time on questions like "how did the most wanted man in the country sneak up on so many cautious people who knew he was coming?"

Paul Emil Erdman: Zero coupon (Hardcover, 1993, Tom Doherty Associates, Inc./Forge, Forge) No rating

"First edition: October 1993"

I needed a semi-mindless book today. I'm a third of the way through now. So far the financial aspects are interesting, the misogyny is ridiculous enough to be funny (this must be the last time someone called a woman in a bar a "dame" unironically) and the writing in general is mediocre.

Thomas Hardy: Tess of the D'Urbervilles (Wordsworth Classics) (Wordsworth Classics) (Paperback, 1997, NTC/Contemporary Publishing Company) No rating

Content warning Spoilers

Andreas Malm: How to Blow up a Pipeline (2020, Verso Books) 3 stars

Why resisting climate change means combatting the fossil fuel industry

The science on climate change …

Instead of provocative questions, Malm offers disregard for the reader and the future

2 stars

It's not clear how this book is intended to be used. There are four main threads running through the text: 1. Malm regaling his own protest experiences deflating car tires and marching on coal mines. 2. Bemoaning how the rich are destroying the planet and condemnation for city-dwellers who own SUVs 3. References to protest movements, both violent and non-violent, around the world 4. Questions about when and how people concerned with climate change should take physical action.

I'll address each on its own.

Malm's personal experience The first, in which Malm describes his own participation in protests, is unimpressive. He's very proud of the time he and his friends snuck around a city and deflated the tires on SUVs. But it's not clear what good it did. The owners were annoyed, some of them threatened the perpetrators online, and there was a drop in SUV sales in Sweden the …

Andreas Malm: How to Blow up a Pipeline (2020, Verso Books) 3 stars

Why resisting climate change means combatting the fossil fuel industry

The science on climate change …

I saw the movie the other day and it was better than I expected. I know it's only loosely inspired by the book, but I still decided to check it out.

If anyone has suggestions for similar movies (like that one, Night Moves and The East) I'd be happy to hear. @Sproid@books.theunseen.city you know of any?

John Scalzi: The Kaiju Preservation Society (EBook, 2022, Tom Doherty Associates) 4 stars

Jamie’s dream was to hit the big time at a New York tech start-up. Jamie’s …

Good story, terrible characters

3 stars

The story is fun and creative. It's too bad the characters are so poorly written. By the end of the book I had trouble focusing on anything else.

The characters are all the same. Whether it's a science fiction loving delivery guy, a brilliant scientist, a billionaire tech bro or an experienced military officer, they all have identical mannerisms and speech. If you take any dialogue out of context there's no way to guess who said it.. Everyone is calm and snarky in the face of death, and more interested in getting a quick jab against the scene's designated punching bag than in what's best for themselves in the long term.

Far better than I expected

4 stars

The author falls strongly on the hero-worshipping side of Lawrence followers, but still wrote a captivating book about a fascinating person.

I didn't know much about T.E. Lawrence before reading Hero. I've seen Lawrence of Arabia many times but still haven't opened my copy of Seven Pillars of Wisdom. I began the book expecting it to be like biographies of Siegfried Sassoon and Apsley Cherry-Garrard, Lawrence's contemporaries who had fascinating youths during the time of World War I, then spent the rest of their lives trying to relive those few years.

Lawrence constantly changed and grew. Each stage of his life was like encountering a new man, and held my attention to the end.