Justin Younger reviewed Seveneves by Neal Stephenson
Review of 'Seveneves' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
I hated less than I enjoyed. Could have been great if it were under half as long.
Paperback, 872 pages
English language
Published May 16, 2016 by The Borough Press.
When a catastrophic event renders the earth a ticking time bomb, it triggers a feverish race against the inevitable. An ambitious plan is devised to ensure the survival of humanity far beyond our atmosphere...
Five thousand years later, the survivors' progeny embark on another audacious journey into the unknown, to an alien world utterly transformed by cataclysm and time: Earth.
I hated less than I enjoyed. Could have been great if it were under half as long.
All of the positive raving for this book is true! All of the criticisms are also true! Stephenson is his own thing and he breaks all the rules of fiction. He breaks them in a couple different ways in this book. When it's great it's REALLY GREAT. When it's not so great, it kinda sucks. At different moments, I wanted to give this five stars. It's a hell of a book and I absolutely recommend it to any "hard" SF fans. Know that the exposition can really be a brick wall in the storytelling and it's not artfully done at all. But Stephenson has certainly earned himself a place on the hard-core SF shelf with this one (if he hadn't already).
Loved this, for the most part, even the scientific explanations which I can see some finding boring. The only reason I'm giving it a 4 rather than a 5 is uneven pacing. It was a page turner at times, but tended to lag in others. I understand this, because it required a lot of world building etc, but I think it could have been done more evenly.
Mixed reaction after finishing this. On the positive side: I learned a ton (orbital mechanics, nuclear power, space travel, evolution, genetics), and I can't recall reading another book anything like it. Stephenson challenges the reader in ways that other authors don't dare, and I admire that.
However, for me the book lacked a certain emotion, a sense of humanity... which, given its subject matter, felt terribly ironic. For long stretches it was hard to stay invested in the outcome. The first 2/3 were much more epic in scope; in the end, it came down to a discordant set of very small interactions that felt at odds with the magnitude of what was happening.
Complex but well-managed; fairly feminist with some notably lazy exceptions. Ends abruptly and raggedly in true Stephenson fashion.
Something I found jarring was that he takes such care to cover the provenance, maintenance, and sustainability of obvious things like computer chips as well as subtler necessaries like eyeglass grinders and paper... but completely fails to mention textiles. Not even a passing reference. Disappointing.
First two thirds good, let down by last third.
There are some fascinating elements to this spec fiction, though I'll admit that much of the more technical pictures Stephenson paints are beyond me. Still, as a mental exercise, this was great fun.
Neal Stephenson came to the fore with his third book Snow Crash, which gave William Gibson a run for his money in the cyberpunk stakes. Since then he’s established his credentials with a range of novels tackling, and often melding, diverse subjects such as cryptography, nanotechnology and cybercrime as well as a three-volume historical sequence – The Baroque Cycle – about the dawning of the Enlightenment in the 17th and 18th centuries.
His latest work, Seveneves, is a huge book, and not just in concept. It runs to 880 pages. The first two-thirds contain one of the best science fiction novels I’ve read this year. The back third – frustratingly – not so much. But still I’d encourage you to read it.
Seveneves begins with ‘Zero’: the moon blows apart for unknown – and perhaps unknowable – reasons. Humanity is stunned. The pieces of the moon still hang …
Neal Stephenson came to the fore with his third book Snow Crash, which gave William Gibson a run for his money in the cyberpunk stakes. Since then he’s established his credentials with a range of novels tackling, and often melding, diverse subjects such as cryptography, nanotechnology and cybercrime as well as a three-volume historical sequence – The Baroque Cycle – about the dawning of the Enlightenment in the 17th and 18th centuries.
His latest work, Seveneves, is a huge book, and not just in concept. It runs to 880 pages. The first two-thirds contain one of the best science fiction novels I’ve read this year. The back third – frustratingly – not so much. But still I’d encourage you to read it.
Seveneves begins with ‘Zero’: the moon blows apart for unknown – and perhaps unknowable – reasons. Humanity is stunned. The pieces of the moon still hang together in the same orbital path, colliding gently with one another every now and then. But Doc Dubois Harris (‘Doob’), a popular TV scientist (think a down-home version of Carl Sagan), works out that those collisions will become worse over time and eventually most of the moon will fall to Earth. They call it the ‘Hard Rain’.
‘It is going to be a meteorite bombardment such as the Earth has not seen since the primordial age, when the solar system formed,’ Doob said. ‘Those fiery trails we’ve been seeing in the sky lately, as the meteorites come in and burn up? There will be so many of those that they will merge into a dome of fire that will set aflame anything that can see it. The entire surface of the Earth is going to be sterilised. Glaciers will boil. The only way to survive is to get away from the atmosphere. Go underground, or go into space.’
‘Well, obviously that is very hard news if it is true,’ the president said.
They all sat and thought about it silently for a period of time that might have been one minute or five.
‘We will have to do both,’ the president said. ‘Go into space, and underground. Obviously the latter is easier.’
… The chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff said, ‘Dr Harris, I’m an old logistics guy. I deal in stuff. How much stuff do we need to get underground? How many sacks of potatoes and rolls of toilet paper per occupant? I guess what I’m asking is, just how long is the Hard Rain going to last?’
Doob said, ‘My best estimate is that it will last somewhere between five thousand and ten thousand years.’
‘Beyond that, I just want you to listen to her. Because I think that she will try to bring you over to her side. It’s what she does with everyone. You would be a prize catch.’
‘If she does as you predict,’ Tekla said, ‘what should be my response?’
It was a measure of Ivy’s naiveté that she didn’t even follow Tekla’s question at first. Then she understood that Tekla was suggesting she might pretend to become one of Julia’s followers. She was volunteering to become a mole in Julia’s network.
Tekla stolidly watched Ivy’s face as Ivy figured it out.
‘I would suggest taking no immediate action,’ Ivy said. Which, in truth, was Ivy being not so much cagey as timid.
‘Of course,’ said Tekla, ‘to show eagerness is poor tactics, it will only arouse her suspicion.’
Ivy said nothing. Tekla explained, ‘I know many people with such minds.’ And you obviously don’t, honey.
I always viewed the third part of [Seveneves] as an opportunity to showcase many of the more positive ideas that have emerged, over the last century, from the global community of people interested in space exploration.