Alex Cabe reviewed Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir
Great procedural writing, meh characters
4 stars
4.5 stars for procedural/plotting, 2 stars for characters. Averages out to 4 stars because there's a lot more of the former.
Excellent procedural problem-solving writing and enthusiasm for science that bleeds through the page. The science facts and problems were fun.
I found the characters pretty flat. Noone other than Grace passes the Phantom Menace test, and Grace's emotional arc didn't work for me at all. The reveal toward the end wasn't justified by what happened before or after.
Looking forward to the movie, wondering how they'll make it work with Rocky's speech and the timeline.
4.5 stars for procedural/plotting, 2 stars for characters. Averages out to 4 stars because there's a lot more of the former.
Excellent procedural problem-solving writing and enthusiasm for science that bleeds through the page. The science facts and problems were fun.
I found the characters pretty flat. Noone other than Grace passes the Phantom Menace test, and Grace's emotional arc didn't work for me at all. The reveal toward the end wasn't justified by what happened before or after.
Looking forward to the movie, wondering how they'll make it work with Rocky's speech and the timeline.